AgentSkillsCN

claude-second-opinion

仅适用于非Claude代理（Codex、Gemini）。当面对存在不确定权衡或多种可行方案的决策时，可借助Claude CLI获取外部的第二意见。Claude代理则应改用gemini-second-opinion。

SKILL.md
--- frontmatter
name: claude-second-opinion
description: "For non-Claude agents only (Codex, Gemini). Get an external second opinion from Claude CLI on a decision with uncertain trade-offs or multiple viable options. Claude agents must use gemini-second-opinion instead."

Claude Second Opinion

Get an alternative perspective from Claude CLI on any decision, design, or code.

Task

  1. •

    Self-Check (CRITICAL):

    • •Are you acting as a Claude agent (Claude Code, Claude CLI)?
    • •If YES: STOP IMMEDIATELY. Do not proceed. Consulting yourself is redundant and wasteful. Use gemini-second-opinion instead for an external second opinion.
    • •If NO (e.g., you are Codex or Gemini): Proceed to step 1.
  2. •

    Gather the context for the second opinion:

    • •If $ARGUMENTS contains a specific question, use it as-is
    • •If working on code, include relevant file contents or diff
    • •If evaluating a design decision, summarize the options being considered
  3. •

    Construct a prompt and run Claude CLI:

    bash
    claude --no-sandbox -p "<constructed prompt>"
  4. •

    Run Claude CLI using environment-specific handling:

    • •If running in Codex CLI (long-running-safe flow):
      1. •Start Claude in background and capture logs to a temp file.
      2. •Save PID and poll every 10-15 seconds.
      3. •Use a hard timeout (default: 300 seconds).
      4. •If timeout is hit, report that Claude is still running and include the latest log tail (do not block indefinitely).
      5. •If process exits non-zero, report failure and include stderr/log tail.
    • •Otherwise: run synchronously and wait for result
  5. •

    Present Claude's response alongside your own analysis, highlighting agreements and disagreements

Prompt Construction

Wrap the context and question for Claude as follows:

code
You are providing a second opinion on a technical decision.

Context:
<context from the current task>

Question:
<the specific question or decision point>

Provide your independent analysis. If you disagree with the current approach, explain why and suggest alternatives.

Rules

  • •Claude Agent Restriction: DO NOT activate or use this skill if you are already a Claude model. Consulting yourself is redundant. This skill is intended for non-Claude agents (like Codex or Gemini) to get a Claude perspective.
  • •Always present both your perspective and Claude's perspective
  • •Clearly label which opinion comes from which model
  • •If Claude's response contradicts your current approach, explain the trade-offs of each approach
  • •Do NOT blindly adopt Claude's suggestion - evaluate it critically
  • •Keep the Claude prompt focused and under 2000 characters for reliability
  • •In Codex CLI, always provide progress updates while polling and avoid silent waits longer than 15 seconds
  • •In Codex CLI, do not lose intermediate output: preserve and summarize partial logs on timeout/error