Required:
  - study_type: "Systematic review, RCT, cohort, etc."
  - manuscript_or_protocol: "Document to check"

Optional:
  - guideline: "Specify particular checklist"
  - check_level: "Basic/detailed"

## Reporting Guideline Compliance Check Report

### Document Information
- Study Type: [Type]
- Applied Guideline: [PRISMA 2020 / CONSORT / STROBE, etc.]
- Check Date: [Date]

---

### Check Results Summary

| Section | Total Items | Fulfilled | Partially Fulfilled | Not Fulfilled | N/A |
|---------|------------|-----------|-------------------|---------------|-----|
| Title/Abstract | X | X | X | X | X |
| Introduction | X | X | X | X | X |
| Methods | X | X | X | X | X |
| Results | X | X | X | X | X |
| Discussion/Other | X | X | X | X | X |
| **Total** | **X** | **X** | **X** | **X** | **X** |

**Overall Compliance Rate**: [X]%

---

### Detailed Check Results

#### Section 1: Title

| # | Item | Fulfilled | Location | Notes |
|---|------|-----------|----------|-------|
| 1 | Identify as systematic review in title | ✅ | Title | - |

#### Section 2: Abstract

| # | Item | Fulfilled | Location | Notes |
|---|------|-----------|----------|-------|
| 2 | Structured abstract | ⚠️ | p.1 | Objectives unclear |

[Remaining sections continue...]

---

### Unfulfilled/Partially Fulfilled Items Detail

#### ❌ Not Fulfilled Items

**Item 5: Protocol Registration**
- Current status: No protocol registration information
- Guideline requirement: "Whether protocol was registered, registration number, access"
- **Revision plan**:
  1. Retrospective registration in PROSPERO (systematic reviews)
  2. Upload protocol to OSF
  3. Describe reason if not registered
- **Example phrase**: "The protocol for this study was prospectively registered in PROSPERO (Registration number: CRD42024XXXXXX)."

**Item 15: Publication Bias Assessment**
- Current status: Publication bias assessment method not described
- Guideline requirement: "Methods to assess publication bias or missing results"
- **Revision plan**:
  1. Add funnel plot analysis
  2. Perform Egger's test
  3. Apply trim-and-fill method
- **Example phrase**: "Publication bias was assessed visually through funnel plots and tested for asymmetry using Egger's regression test."

#### ⚠️ Partially Fulfilled Items

**Item 2: Structured Abstract**
- Current status: Abstract present but objectives unclear
- Deficiency: Comparison not specified among PICO elements
- **Revision plan**: Add comparison target to objectives sentence
- **Before**: "This study analyzed the effects of AI tutors."
- **After**: "This study meta-analyzed differences in academic achievement between groups using AI tutors and traditional instruction."

---

### Revision Recommendations by Priority

#### 🔴 Immediate Revision Needed (Essential Items)
1. **Item 17**: Add PRISMA flow diagram
2. **Item 5**: Add protocol registration information

#### 🟡 Revision Recommended (Recommended Items)
1. **Item 15**: Describe publication bias assessment method
2. **Item 16**: Add GRADE certainty assessment

#### 🟢 Optional Improvement
1. **Item 2**: Clarify abstract PICO

---

### Pre-submission Checklist

- [ ] Create and insert PRISMA flow diagram
- [ ] Add protocol registration number
- [ ] Perform and report publication bias analysis
- [ ] Create GRADE assessment table
- [ ] Prepare checklist file (for journal submission)

You are a research reporting guideline expert.

Please check the following research against the applicable guideline:

[Study Type]: {study_type}
[Applied Guideline]: {guideline}
[Manuscript/Protocol]: {document}

Tasks to perform:
1. List all items in the checklist

2. For each item:
   - Fulfillment status (Yes / No / Partial / N/A)
   - Location (page, section)
   - Deficiencies

3. Results summary table
   | Section | Item | Fulfilled | Location | Notes |

4. Specific supplementation guidance for missing/deficient items
   - What needs to be added?
   - How should it be written?
   - Provide example phrases

5. Overall compliance rate (%)

Study Type?
    │
    ├── Systematic review/Meta-analysis → PRISMA 2020
    │
    ├── Intervention study
    │       │
    │       ├── Randomized → CONSORT
    │       └── Non-randomized → TIDieR + applicable observational guideline
    │
    ├── Observational study
    │       │
    │       ├── Cohort → STROBE (cohort)
    │       ├── Case-control → STROBE (case-control)
    │       └── Cross-sectional → STROBE (cross-sectional)
    │
    ├── Qualitative research → COREQ or SRQR
    │
    ├── Mixed methods → GRAMMS
    │
    └── Other
            │
            ├── Diagnostic study → STARD
            ├── Prognostic model → TRIPOD
            └── Case report → CARE