AgentSkillsCN

review-mode

对最新提出的方案进行批判性审视，查找漏洞并提出改进建议。

SKILL.md
--- frontmatter
name: review-mode
description:
  Critically reviews the last proposed plan for flaws and improvements.

Review mode

GOAL: critically review the last strategic plan to identify flaws, logical errors, missed edge cases, or improvements before user approval.

WHEN: user requests a review of a plan or strategy.

NOTE: operates in READ-ONLY mode. MUST NOT change code.

Efficiency directives

  • •Optimize all operations for token and context efficiency
  • •Batch operations on file groups, avoid individual file processing
  • •Use parallel execution when possible
  • •Target only relevant files
  • •Reduce token usage

Workflow

Step 1: Activate read-only

  • •Invoke readonly-mode skill.

Step 2: Analyze plan (perceive)

  • •Fully understand plan objectives.
  • •Assess from all specialist perspectives (Security, QA, Architecture, Performance, DevOps).
  • •Compare against kbase best practices.

Step 3: Critique (reason)

  • •Check risk classification.
  • •Surface missing considerations.
  • •Synthesize decision (APPROVE/REVISE/REJECT).

Step 4: Present review

  • •Output the review using the structure defined below.
  • •DONE

Output structure

Review checklist:

  1. •

    As a Security Engineer

    • •Vulnerability Assessment
    • •Security Controls
    • •Findings (Critical, Moderate, Best Practices)
  2. •

    As a QA Engineer

    • •Test Coverage
    • •Quality Assurance
    • •Test Quality
    • •Findings (Critical, Moderate, Best Practices)
  3. •

    As a Senior Architect

    • •Design & Architecture
    • •Code Quality
    • •Long-term Considerations
    • •Findings (Critical, Moderate, Best Practices)
  4. •

    As a Performance Engineer

    • •Performance Impact
    • •Optimization Opportunities
    • •Performance Metrics
    • •Findings (Critical, Moderate, Best Practices)
  5. •

    As a DevOps Engineer

    • •Deployment & Operations
    • •Operational Concerns
    • •Infrastructure
    • •Findings (Critical, Moderate, Best Practices)

Knowledge base alignment:

  • •Pattern Compliance
  • •Deviations

Risk re-assessment:

  • •Original vs. Re-assessed Risk Level
  • •Justification

Review decision:

  • •Recommendation: APPROVE ✅ / REVISE 🔄 / REJECT ❌
  • •Critical Issues (Blockers)
  • •Moderate Concerns (Recommendations)
  • •Minor Observations
  • •Confidence Level: HIGH 🟢 / MEDIUM 🟡 / LOW 🔴
  • •Next Steps

Review summary:

  • •Strengths
  • •Weaknesses
  • •Assessment