AgentSkillsCN

review-paper

全面审视论文稿件，涵盖论证结构、识别策略、计量经济模型设定、引用完整性，以及可能面临的审稿人异议。

SKILL.md
--- frontmatter
name: review-paper
description: Comprehensive manuscript review covering argument structure, identification strategy, econometric specification, citation completeness, and potential referee objections.
disable-model-invocation: true
argument-hint: "[paper filename in master_supporting_docs/ or path to .tex/.pdf]"
allowed-tools: ["Read", "Grep", "Glob", "Write", "Task"]

Review Paper

Produce a thorough referee-style review of an academic manuscript.

Steps

  1. •

    Identify the paper: Use $ARGUMENTS. Check master_supporting_docs/supporting_papers/ or the paper folder.

  2. •

    Evaluate across 6 dimensions (rate each 1-5):

    • •Argument Structure: Research question clarity, logical flow, evidence support, limitations acknowledged
    • •Identification Strategy: Causal claim credibility, identifying assumptions stated, threats discussed, robustness checks proposed
    • •Econometric Specification: Standard errors appropriate, functional form justified, sample selection discussed, multiple testing addressed, economic meaningfulness vs statistical significance
    • •Literature Positioning: Key citations present, accurate characterization, clear differentiation, missing citations identified
    • •Writing Quality: Clarity, tone, notation consistency, abstract quality, self-contained tables/figures
    • •Presentation: Table/figure design, notation consistency across sections, typos, paper length
  3. •

    Generate 3-5 likely referee objections with suggested responses.

  4. •

    Overall recommendation: Strong Accept / Accept / Revise & Resubmit / Reject.

  5. •

    Save report to quality_reports/paper_review_[sanitized_name].md.

Notes

  • •Be constructive. Identify strengths alongside weaknesses.
  • •Distinguish CRITICAL (math wrong) from MAJOR (missing discussion) from MINOR (could be clearer).