GFRP Structural Design Standards Expert

Use this skill when users ask questions about GFRP (Glass Fiber Reinforced Polymer) structural design, ASCE/SEI 74-23 standard, pultruded composites, orthotropic materials, fiber reinforced polymers, or composite structural systems.

Trigger Keywords

English: GFRP, FRP, glass fiber, fiber reinforced polymer, pultruded, pultrusion, ASCE 74, composite structures, orthotropic, anisotropic, time effect factor, environmental factors, bearing strength, creep rupture, laminate, resin matrix

Korean: GFRP, FRP, 섬유강화플라스틱, 복합재료, 펄트루전, 펄트루젼, 유리섬유, 직교이방성, 이방성, 시간효과계수, 환경조정계수, 지압강도, 크리프파괴, 적층, 수지매트릭스

Tools Required

• •Grep: Search for keywords in ASCE/SEI 74-23 documents
• •Read: Read specific chapters and reference files
• •Glob: Pattern matching to find files
• •Bash: Execute Python scripts for searches and calculations
• •Write: (Optional) Save calculation results or reports

Document Structure

This skill provides access to comprehensive GFRP design documentation:

1. ASCE/SEI 74-23 Specification (Chapters 1-9)

Location: data/specification/*.md (5 part files covering 125 pages)

Purpose: What you must follow - formulas, requirements, limits, design criteria using LRFD method

Chapters:

• •Chapter 1: General Provisions (scope, materials, LRFD basics, load combinations)
• •Chapter 2: Design Requirements (resistance factors φ, time effect λ, environmental factors C_M/C_T/C_CH, second-order analysis, deflection, fatigue)
• •Chapter 3: Tension Members (gross section, net section, pin-connected, threaded rods)
• •Chapter 4: Compression Members (flexural buckling, local flange/web buckling, torsional buckling, effective length)
• •Chapter 5: Flexural Members & Shear (material rupture, lateral-torsional buckling, web shear, shear buckling, concentrated loads)
• •Chapter 6: Combined Forces (beam-columns, torsion, interaction equations)
• •Chapter 7: Plates and Built-Up Members (in-plane loading, open-hole strength, pull-through, two-way bending)
• •Chapter 8: Bolted Connections (6+ failure modes: bearing, net tension, shear-out, block shear, pull-through, bolt shear)
• •Chapter 9: Seismic Design (R factors, braced frames, cooling towers)

Appendices:

• •Appendix A: Symbols and Notations (complete variable definitions)
• •Appendix B: Glossary (technical terms)
• •Appendix C8.3.2: Multi-row bolted connection full formul as

2. Commentary (Chapters C1-C9)

Location: Integrated within the 5 part files

Purpose: Understand why - background, research basis, design philosophy

Contents: Detailed commentary for each chapter with:

• •Historical development and research citations
• •Design examples and comparisons
• •Limit state explanations
• •Special considerations for GFRP orthotropic behavior
• •Reliability basis for resistance factors

3. Reference Files

Location: references/ directory (8 comprehensive guides)

This skill includes essential reference materials:

• •symbols.md: Complete symbols table (150+ variables with units, sections)
• •glossary.md: Technical terms and definitions (50+ terms)
• •abbreviations.md: ASTM standards, acronyms, units, conversions
• •chapter-structure.md: Complete chapter mapping and navigation guide
• •material-properties-guide.md: Typical GFRP properties, testing requirements, statistical basis
• •environmental-factors.md: C_M, C_T, C_CH adjustment factors with tables
• •resistance-factors.md: φ values by failure mode (0.50-0.85) with rationale
• •time-effect-factors.md: λ values by load duration (0.60-1.00) with examples

Automation Scripts

Python scripts available in scripts/ directory:

• •smart_search.py: Category-aware keyword search (maps keywords to chapters)
• •formula_finder.py: Extract formulas with context (±5 lines)
• •material_lookup.py: Property lookup with typical ranges
• •environmental_adjustment.py: Calculate adjusted strengths (F_adjusted = F × C_M × C_T × C_CH)
• •connection_checker.py: Multi-mode connection design helper (6+ failure modes)

Workflow by Query Type

1. Formula Query (공식 질의)

User Intent: Find specific formula or equation from ASCE/SEI 74-23 Specification.

Example Queries:

• •"What is the formula for lateral-torsional buckling of GFRP beams?"
• •"Show me the compression buckling equation"
• •"GFRP 보의 전단좌굴 공식을 알려줘"

Quick Process:

1. •Identify topic (flexure → Chapter 5, compression → Chapter 4, connections → Chapter 8, etc.)
2. •Grep relevant chapter file in data/specification/
3. •Extract formula with variable definitions from references/symbols.md
4. •Note orthotropic dependency: Check if formula uses E_L, E_T, G_LT (direction-dependent)
5. •Note environmental factors: Remind user to apply C_M, C_T, C_CH adjustments
6. •Present with ASCE citation (e.g., "ASCE/SEI 74-23 Section 5.2.2")

GFRP-Specific Considerations:

• •Formulas often include √(E_L × E_T) for orthotropic effects
• •Multiple buckling modes must be checked (flexural, local flange, local web, torsional)
• •Environmental factors must be applied to all material properties
• •Time effect factor λ must be considered for load duration

Keywords: formula, equation, 공식, 계산식, buckling, strength

2. Material Properties Query (물성값 질의 - GFRP-SPECIFIC)

User Intent: Find typical GFRP material properties or understand testing requirements.

Example Queries:

• •"What is typical longitudinal modulus for pultruded GFRP?"
• •"What's the difference between E_L and E_T?"
• •"GFRP의 전형적인 인장강도는 얼마야?"
• •"How do I determine characteristic values?"

Quick Process:

1. •Check references/material-properties-guide.md for quick reference
2. •Identify property type (elastic moduli, strengths, thermal)
3. •Return typical ranges with caveats:
   • •E_L: 2,000-4,000 ksi (14-28 GPa)
   • •E_T: 800-1,500 ksi (40-50% of E_L)
   • •G_LT: 300-600 ksi (~15% of E_L)
   • •F_L^t: 30-50 ksi (210-345 MPa)
   • •F_L^c: 20-40 ksi (60-80% of F_L^t)
4. •Emphasize testing requirement: All properties must be determined per ASTM D6121 or D7290
5. •Explain statistical basis (75% confidence, 20% exclusion limit)
6. •Note orthotropic behavior (L vs T direction differences)

Typical GFRP Properties Table:

Testing Standards Reference:

• •ASTM D3039: Tensile properties
• •ASTM D3410/D695: Compressive properties
• •ASTM D5379: Shear properties (V-notched beam)
• •ASTM D6121: Characteristic values determination
• •ASTM D7290: Filled-hole properties
• •ASTM E1640: Glass transition temperature

Keywords: properties, modulus, strength, E_L, E_T, testing, characteristic value, 물성, 탄성계수, 강도

3. Environmental Adjustment Query (환경보정 질의 - GFRP-SPECIFIC)

User Intent: Apply environmental factors to adjust material properties for end-use conditions.

Example Queries:

• •"How does moisture affect GFRP strength?"
• •"What C_M factor should I use for wet service?"
• •"Calculate adjusted strength for hot, wet, chemical exposure"
• •"습윤환경에서 GFRP 강도감소는?"

Quick Process:

1. •Identify exposure conditions (moisture, temperature, chemicals)
2. •Check references/environmental-factors.md for factor values
3. •Determine appropriate factors:
   • •C_M (moisture): 0.70-1.00 (dry=1.00, wet=0.75-0.85, immersed=0.70-0.80)
   • •C_T (temperature): 0.75-1.00 (< 100°F=1.00, check T vs T_g)
   • •C_CH (chemical): 0.50-1.00 (varies by chemical type and pH)
   • •C_CA (composite action): 0.60-1.00 (for built-up members)
   • •C_LS (load sharing): 1.00-1.15 (for multiple parallel members)
4. •Apply adjustment formula: F_adjusted = F_reference × C_M × C_T × C_CH × C_CA × C_LS
5. •Use scripts/environmental_adjustment.py for automated calculation
6. •Warning: Combined effects can reduce capacity 30-50%!

Environmental Factors Quick Table:

Critical Reminders:

• •Apply factors to ALL material properties (E_L, E_T, F_L^t, F_L^c, F_LT^s, etc.)
• •Test in actual service environment when critical
• •Combined hot + wet is worse than sum of individual effects
• •Glass transition temperature T_g is absolute limit (typically 180-250°F)

Keywords: environmental, moisture, temperature, chemical, C_M, C_T, C_CH, adjustment, wet, 환경, 습기, 온도, 화학

4. Time Effect Factor Query (시간효과계수 질의 - GFRP-SPECIFIC)

User Intent: Apply time effect factor for load duration effects (creep rupture).

Example Queries:

• •"What λ factor for dead load?"
• •"Time effect factor for snow load combination"
• •"Why does GFRP have time-dependent strength?"
• •"지속하중에 대한 강도감소는?"

Quick Process:

1. •Identify load duration from load combination
2. •Check references/time-effect-factors.md for λ values
3. •Return appropriate factor:
   • •Permanent (50+ years): λ = 0.60 (dead load only)
   • •10 years: λ = 0.70 (D + L combinations)
   • •2 months: λ = 0.80 (D + S combinations)
   • •7 days: λ = 0.90 (D + L_r combinations)
   • •10 minutes: λ = 1.00 (D + W, D + E combinations)
4. •Use shortest significant duration in load combination
5. •Explain creep rupture mechanism (matrix creep, stress concentrations over time)

Time Effect Factors Table (ASCE/SEI 74-23 Table 2-1):

Load Combination Examples:

• •1.4D → λ = 0.60 (dead only)
• •1.2D + 1.6L → λ = 0.70 (live controls)
• •1.2D + 1.6S → λ = 0.80 (snow controls)
• •1.2D + 1.0W → λ = 1.00 (wind controls)
• •1.2D + 1.0E → λ = 1.00 (seismic controls)

Design Equation: $$R_u \leq \phi \lambda R_n$$

Combined with φ example:

• •Flexure: φ = 0.75, λ = 0.70 (D+L case)
• •Design strength = 0.75 × 0.70 × M_n = 0.525 M_n (~50% of nominal!)

Keywords: time effect, duration, creep, λ, lambda, sustained load, permanent, 시간효과, 지속하중, 크리프

5. Calculation Query (계산 질의)

User Intent: Perform structural calculations using ASCE/SEI 74-23 formulas with GFRP-specific considerations.

Example Queries:

• •"Calculate lateral-torsional buckling: GFRP I-beam, L_b=10ft, wet service"
• •"Determine compression capacity: GFRP tube 6x6x0.375, KL=12ft, hot environment"
• •"GFRP 보의 휨강도를 계산해줘: W12x6, 습윤환경, 설하중 조합"

Quick Process:

1. •Identify all input parameters:
   • •Section properties (shape, dimensions)
   • •Material properties (E_L, E_T, G_LT, F_L^t, F_L^c, F_LT^s)
   • •Environmental conditions (wet/dry, temperature, chemicals)
   • •Load duration (permanent, 10-year, snow, wind, seismic)
   • •Unbraced lengths, boundary conditions
2. •Apply environmental adjustments:
   • •Determine C_M, C_T, C_CH factors
   • •Adjust ALL material properties: F_adjusted = F_ref × C_M × C_T × C_CH
3. •Find relevant formula from Specification (use Formula Query workflow)
4. •Check MULTIPLE limit states (GFRP often has 3-4 competing modes):
   • •Flexure: Material rupture, LTB, local flange buckling, local web buckling
   • •Compression: Flexural buckling, local flange, local web, torsional, flexural-torsional
   • •Connections: Bearing, net tension, shear-out, block shear, pull-through, bolt shear
5. •Apply resistance factor φ (varies by failure mode: 0.50-0.85)
6. •Apply time effect factor λ (varies by load duration: 0.60-1.00)
7. •Generate Python code following ASCE examples
8. •Execute and validate

GFRP-Specific Checks (CRITICAL):

• •✅ Orthotropic properties specified (E_L, E_T, G_LT all required)
• •✅ Environmental factors applied (C_M, C_T, C_CH)
• •✅ Time effect factor applied (λ)
• •✅ Glass transition temperature verified (T_service < T_g - 20°F)
• •✅ Multiple buckling modes checked
• •✅ Direction of loading identified (longitudinal vs transverse)
• •✅ Serviceability checked (deflection often controls due to low E)

Example Calculation Framework:

# GFRP Beam Flexural Strength Calculation
# ASCE/SEI 74-23 Section 5.2

# 1. Material Properties (from testing per ASTM D6121)
E_L = 3000  # ksi, longitudinal modulus
E_T = 1200  # ksi, transverse modulus
G_LT = 450  # ksi, shear modulus
F_Lc = 35  # ksi, longitudinal compressive strength (reference)
F_Lt = 40  # ksi, longitudinal tensile strength (reference)
nu_LT = 0.30  # Poisson's ratio

# 2. Environmental Adjustment Factors (Section 2.4)
C_M = 0.85  # Wet service
C_T = 0.90  # Sustained 130°F
C_CH = 1.00  # No chemicals
# Adjusted strengths
F_Lc_adj = F_Lc * C_M * C_T * C_CH  # = 35 * 0.85 * 0.90 = 26.8 ksi
F_Lt_adj = F_Lt * C_M * C_T * C_CH  # = 40 * 0.85 * 0.90 = 30.6 ksi

# 3. Section Properties
S_x = 15.0  # in^3, section modulus
I_y = 5.0  # in^4, weak axis moment of inertia
J = 0.5  # in^4, torsion constant
L_b = 120  # in, unbraced length

# 4. Check Limit States
# (a) Material Rupture (Section 5.2.1)
M_n_rupture = S_x * F_Lc_adj  # = 15.0 * 26.8 = 402 kip-in

# (b) Lateral-Torsional Buckling (Section 5.2.2)
import math
C_b = 1.0  # Conservative (uniform moment)
M_n_LTB = C_b * math.sqrt(E_L * I_y * G_LT * J)  # Equation 5-7
# = 1.0 * sqrt(3000 * 5.0 * 450 * 0.5) = 1.0 * sqrt(3,375,000) = 1,837 kip-in

# (c) Local Buckling: Check flange and web per Section 5.2.3, 5.2.4
# (Not shown for brevity, but must be checked)

# 5. Controlling Limit State
M_n = min(M_n_rupture, M_n_LTB)  # = min(402, 1837) = 402 kip-in
controlling_mode = "Material Rupture"

# 6. Apply Resistance Factor (Section 2.3.2)
phi = 0.75  # Flexure resistance factor

# 7. Apply Time Effect Factor (Section 2.3.3)
lambda_factor = 0.80  # Snow load (2-month duration)

# 8. Design Strength
M_design = phi * lambda_factor * M_n
# = 0.75 * 0.80 * 402 = 241 kip-in

print(f"Nominal Strength: {M_n:.1f} kip-in ({controlling_mode})")
print(f"Design Strength: {M_design:.1f} kip-in")
print(f"Reduction Factors: φ={phi}, λ={lambda_factor}")

Keywords: calculate, compute, determine, design, capacity, strength, 계산, 산정, 설계, 강도

6. Connection Design Query (연결부 설계 - GFRP-SPECIFIC)

User Intent: Design bolted connections considering multiple failure modes.

Example Queries:

• •"Design GFRP bolted connection: 3/4" bolt, e1=3", e2=2", t=0.5""
• •"Check all failure modes for multi-row connection"
• •"볼트연결부 설계: 볼트 4개, FRP-to-steel"

Quick Process:

1. •Identify connection geometry:
   • •Bolt diameter d_b, hole diameter d_h
   • •End distance e_1, edge distance e_2
   • •Pitch spacing s, gage g
   • •Plate thickness t, number of bolts n, number of rows n_r
   • •Materials connected (FRP-FRP vs FRP-steel)
   • •Angle θ (connection force vs pultrusion direction)
2. •Check minimum geometry requirements (Table 8-1):
   • •e_1 ≥ 3d_h
   • •e_2 ≥ 2d_h
   • •s ≥ 3d_h
   • •g ≥ 3d_h
3. •Check ALL 6+ failure modes (Chapter 8.3): a. Bolt shear/tension (φ=0.75): Per AISC for steel bolt b. Bearing (φ=0.65): R_bf = C_b × ζ × F_br × d_b × t c. Net tension (φ=0.50): R_nt = K_nt × F_L^t × (w - d_h) × t d. Shear-out (φ=0.50): R_so = (e_2 + s/2) × t × F_LT^s e. Block shear (φ=0.65): Combined shear + tension tearing f. Pull-through (φ=0.50): R_pt = bearing pressure × washer area
4. •Multi-row load distribution (if n_r > 1):
   • •FRP-steel, 2 rows: 100% / 0%
   • •FRP-steel, 3 rows: 60% / 40% / 0%
   • •FRP-FRP, 2 rows: 60% / 40%
   • •FRP-FRP, 3 rows: 60% / 30% / 20%
5. •Use scripts/connection_checker.py for automated multi-mode checking
6. •Controlling mode: Minimum of all 6+ capacities

Connection Failure Modes Table:

Why Connection φ is Low?:

• •Stress concentrations at holes (brittle)
• •Geometric variability (hole tolerance)
• •Orthotropic bearing behavior
• •No ductility warning before failure
• •Net tension φ=0.50 is lowest in standard!

Multi-Row Example:

# 3-row FRP-to-FRP connection design
n_r = 3  # number of rows
# Load distribution factors (Table C8-1)
f_u1 = 0.60  # 1st row (furthest from free end)
f_u2 = 0.30  # 2nd row
f_u3 = 0.20  # 3rd row (nearest to free end)

# Check each row
R_nt1 = f_u1 * (net tension capacity at row 1)
R_nt2 = f_u2 * (net tension capacity at row 2)
R_nt3 = f_u3 * (net tension capacity at row 3)

# Connection capacity = min of all modes

Use scripts/connection_checker.py:

python3 connection_checker.py \
  --d_b 0.75 --e_1 3.0 --e_2 2.0 --t 0.5 \
  --F_br 40 --F_Lt 35 --F_LTs 7 \
  --n 2 --n_r 2 --material FRP-FRP

Keywords: connection, bolt, bolted, bearing, net tension, shear-out, block shear, pull-through, 연결부, 볼트, 지압, 순인장

7. Terminology Query (용어 설명)

User Intent: Understand meaning and context of GFRP design terminology.

Example Queries:

• •"What is orthotropic behavior?"
• •"Explain time effect factor"
• •"What's the difference between characteristic value and nominal value?"
• •"펄트루전이 뭐야?"

Quick Process:

1. •Check references/glossary.md first
2. •If not found, search "Glossary" sections in Specification (Appendix B)
3. •Present definition with ASCE citation
4. •Provide usage examples from Specification chapters
5. •For GFRP-specific terms: Explain material science background

GFRP-Specific Terminology:

Orthotropic: Material having different properties in three mutually perpendicular directions (L, T, through-thickness). GFRP is orthotropic because continuous fibers run in longitudinal direction.

• •E_L ≠ E_T ≠ E_through-thickness
• •F_L^t >> F_T^t (typically 5:1 to 8:1 ratio)
• •Unlike steel/aluminum which are isotropic (same in all directions)

Pultruded/Pultrusion: Manufacturing process where continuous fibers are pulled through resin bath and heated die, creating constant cross-section shapes. Like "extrusion" but pulling instead of pushing.

Characteristic Value: Statistically determined minimum property value with 75% confidence that at least 80% of population exceeds this value. Per ASTM D6121:

• •NOT the average value
• •NOT the minimum test value
• •Statistical lower bound: F_char = mean - k×std_dev

Time Effect Factor (λ): Reduction factor for sustained loads due to creep rupture. GFRP strength decreases over time under constant stress:

• •Short-term (10 min): λ = 1.00 (full strength)
• •Long-term (50 years): λ = 0.60 (60% strength)
• •Unique to GFRP and wood (metals don't have this)

Glass Transition Temperature (T_g): Critical temperature above which polymer matrix becomes rubbery and loses strength/stiffness. Typically 180-250°F for polyester/vinyl ester systems. Absolute design limit.

Bearing Strength (F_br): Compressive strength of GFRP under localized bolt bearing. Must be determined by testing (ASTM D7290), not calculated from material properties. Varies with:

• •Load angle θ relative to pultrusion direction
• •Bolt diameter to thickness ratio (d/t)
• •Edge distance to diameter ratio (e/d)

Keywords: what is, explain, definition, meaning, 뭐야, 설명, 의미, 정의

8. Symbol/Notation Query (기호 질의)

User Intent: Understand what a mathematical symbol represents.

Example Queries:

• •"What does E_L mean?"
• •"Define C_M moisture factor"
• •"λ 기호는 무엇을 의미하나요?"

Quick Process:

1. •Check references/symbols.md
2. •Return: Symbol | Definition | Units | Section Reference
3. •Example: E_L = Longitudinal elastic modulus | ksi (MPa) | Sections 1.4, 2.3, 4.2, 5.2
4. •For GFRP-specific symbols: Explain orthotropic context

Common GFRP Symbols:

Material Properties:

• •E_L: Longitudinal elastic modulus (parallel to fibers) = 2,000-4,000 ksi
• •E_T: Transverse elastic modulus (perpendicular to fibers) = 800-1,500 ksi (~40% of E_L)
• •G_LT: In-plane shear modulus = 300-600 ksi (~15% of E_L)
• •ν_LT: Poisson's ratio = 0.25-0.35 (typically 0.3)
• •T_g: Glass transition temperature = 180-250°F (critical threshold)

Strengths (with superscripts):

• •F_L^t: Longitudinal tensile strength = 30-50 ksi
• •F_T^t: Transverse tensile strength = 5-10 ksi (much lower!)
• •F_L^c: Longitudinal compressive strength = 20-40 ksi (60-80% of F_L^t)
• •F_LT^s: Longitudinal-transverse shear strength = 4-10 ksi

Adjustment Factors:

• •C_M: Moisture factor (0.70-1.00) - reduces strength for wet service
• •C_T: Temperature factor (0.75-1.00) - reduces strength for elevated temperature
• •C_CH: Chemical factor (0.50-1.00) - reduces strength for aggressive chemicals
• •φ: Resistance factor (0.50-0.85) - accounts for variability, varies by failure mode
• •λ: Time effect factor (0.60-1.00) - accounts for load duration (creep rupture)

Superscripts:

• •^t = tension
• •^c = compression
• •^f = flexure
• •^s = shear

Subscripts:

• •_L = longitudinal direction (0°, direction of pultrusion)
• •_T = transverse direction (90°, perpendicular to pultrusion)
• •_LT = longitudinal-transverse (in-plane shear)
• •_w = web
• •_f = flange

Keywords: symbol, notation, variable, 기호, 표기, 변수

9. Comparison Query (비교 질의)

User Intent: Compare GFRP with steel/aluminum, or compare different GFRP configurations.

Example Queries:

• •"GFRP vs steel structural design differences"
• •"Compare E_L and E_T for GFRP"
• •"GFRP와 철골 설계의 차이는?"
• •"Why is GFRP deflection often critical?"

Quick Process:

1. •Identify items to compare
2. •For GFRP vs metals:
   • •Material properties (E, density, strength)
   • •Design philosophy (LRFD, factors, time effects)
   • •Behavior (ductile vs brittle, isotropic vs orthotropic)
   • •Environmental sensitivity
3. •For GFRP directional comparison (L vs T):
   • •Property ratios (E_L/E_T, F_L^t/F_T^t)
   • •Orthotropic effects in design
4. •Present in comparison table format

GFRP vs Steel Comprehensive Comparison:

GFRP Longitudinal vs Transverse Comparison:

Critical Design Philosophy Differences:

Steel:

• •Yielding provides ductility and warning
• •Properties uniform in all directions
• •No time or environmental effects
• •Deflection rarely controls
• •φ factors higher (0.90 typical)

GFRP:

• •No yielding - brittle failure without warning
• •Orthotropic - must consider L vs T directions
• •Time-dependent - λ factor for creep rupture
• •Environmentally sensitive - C_M, C_T, C_CH factors
• •Deflection often controls - E is 1/12 of steel
• •φ factors lower - especially connections (0.50)
• •Multiple buckling modes - flexural, local flange, local web, torsional

When GFRP is Advantageous:

1. •Corrosion resistance: Chemical plants, marine, wastewater treatment
2. •Lightweight: Roof structures, pedestrian bridges, temporary structures
3. •EMI transparency: Near radar, MRI facilities
4. •Thermal insulation: Cold storage, process equipment
5. •Ease of installation: No welding, lighter crane requirements

When Steel is Better:

1. •Stiffness-critical: Long spans with tight deflection limits
2. •High temperature: Above 200°F sustained
3. •Ductility required: Seismic zones needing R > 3
4. •Fire resistance: Occupied buildings without fireproofing
5. •Cost: Simple structural framing where corrosion not issue

Keywords: compare, difference, vs, 차이, 비교, steel, aluminum, metal, orthotropic, isotropic

10. Serviceability Query (사용성 질의)

User Intent: Check deflection, drift, or vibration criteria.

Example Queries:

• •"What deflection limit for GFRP beams?"
• •"Calculate GFRP beam deflection under service loads"
• •"Why does deflection control GFRP design?"
• •"GFRP 처짐 제한은?"

Quick Process:

1. •Identify serviceability criterion (deflection, drift, vibration)
2. •Note: No φ or λ factors for serviceability!
3. •Use service load combinations (unfactored per ASCE 7)
4. •Use mean modulus values (not characteristic reduced values)
5. •For deflection:
   • •Instantaneous: Standard elastic equation
   • •Long-term creep: Δ_total = Δ_instant × (1 + ψ_creep)
   • •Creep multiplier ψ typically 1.5-3.0 for sustained loads
6. •Compare to limits (Section 2.6):
   • •Floors: L/360 (or L/240 for special cases)
   • •Roofs: L/240 or L/180
   • •Cantilevers: More stringent
7. •Deflection often governs GFRP design!

Why Deflection Controls GFRP:

• •E_GFRP ≈ E_steel / 12 (much more flexible)
• •Deflection ∝ 1/E (inversely proportional)
• •Same load, same span → GFRP deflects 12× more than steel
• •L/360 limit often exceeded unless section is large

Deflection Calculation Example:

# GFRP Simple Beam Deflection
# No φ, no λ for serviceability!

# Service loads (unfactored)
w_D = 50  # plf, dead load
w_L = 100  # plf, live load
L = 20 * 12  # inches, span

# Material (mean values, not reduced)
E_L = 3000  # ksi, mean longitudinal modulus
I = 100  # in^4, moment of inertia

# Instantaneous deflection (elastic)
w_total = w_D + w_L  # = 150 plf
Delta_instant = (5 * w_total * L**4) / (384 * E_L * I)
# = (5 * 150/12 * 240^4) / (384 * 3000 * 100)
# = 2.88 in

# Long-term deflection (creep under sustained load)
psi_creep = 2.0  # Creep multiplier (typical 1.5-3.0)
w_sustained = w_D  # Only dead load is sustained
Delta_creep = psi_creep * (5 * w_sustained * L**4) / (384 * E_L * I)
# = 2.0 * (5 * 50/12 * 240^4) / (384 * 3000 * 100)
# = 0.96 in

Delta_total = Delta_instant + Delta_creep  # = 2.88 + 0.96 = 3.84 in

# Check limits
L_360 = L / 360  # = 240 / 360 = 0.67 in
L_240 = L / 240  # = 240 / 240 = 1.00 in

if Delta_total > L_360:
    print(f"FAILS L/360: {Delta_total:.2f} in > {L_360:.2f} in")
    print("Increase section size or reduce span")
else:
    print(f"OK: {Delta_total:.2f} in < {L_360:.2f} in")

Deflection Limits (Section 2.6):

Drift Limits (lateral):

• •Non-structural elements attached: 0.7% (0.007h)
• •Structural elements only: 2.5% (0.025h)

Vibration:

• •Natural frequency f > 3-5 Hz for floors (walking comfort)
• •Use instantaneous stiffness (no creep for dynamic)

Keywords: deflection, drift, serviceability, L/360, vibration, creep, 처짐, 사용성, 진동

Quick Reference Tables

Document Categories

Common Search Patterns

ASCE/SEI 74-23 Chapter-to-Topic Mapping

Resistance Factors Quick Reference

Lowest φ: Net tension, shear-out, pull-through = 0.50 (most conservative)

Time Effect Factors Quick Reference

Rule: Use shortest significant duration in load combination.

Environmental Factors Quick Reference

Formula: F_adjusted = F_reference × C_M × C_T × C_CH

Warning: Combined effects can reduce capacity 30-50% or more!

Units Convention

Performance Optimization

Search Strategy Priority

1. •

   Chapter identification first:

   • •Use topic keywords to identify specific chapter (1-9)
   • •Don't search all files - target 1-2 relevant chapters
   • •Example: "connection" → Only search Chapter 8
2. •

   Reference files before full search:

   • •Symbols → references/symbols.md
   • •Properties → references/material-properties-guide.md
   • •Factors → references/environmental-factors.md, resistance-factors.md, time-effect-factors.md
   • •Structure → references/chapter-structure.md
3. •

   Efficient chapter targeting:

   • •Connection design → Chapter 8
   • •Beam design → Chapter 5
   • •Column design → Chapter 4
   • •Material/factors → Chapter 2
   • •Example: "GFRP beam LTB" → Only search Chapter 5
4. •

   Smart document reading:

   • •Read only relevant sections
   • •Use offset and limit for large files
   • •Cross-reference Specification and Commentary when needed

Python Script Usage

Execute automation scripts when appropriate:

# Material properties lookup
python3 scripts/material_lookup.py --property "E_L" --typical

# Environmental adjustment calculation
python3 scripts/environmental_adjustment.py \
  --F_ref 35 --C_M 0.85 --C_T 0.90 --C_CH 1.00

# Connection multi-mode checker
python3 scripts/connection_checker.py \
  --d_b 0.75 --e_1 3.0 --e_2 2.0 --t 0.5 \
  --F_br 40 --F_Lt 35 --F_LTs 7 --n 2

# Category-aware search
python3 scripts/smart_search.py "lateral-torsional buckling"

# Extract formula with context
python3 scripts/formula_finder.py "M_n =" "Chapter 5"

Response Quality Checklist

Every response should include:

• •✅ Accurate ASCE citation (ASCE/SEI 74-23 Section X.Y or Chapter X)
• •✅ Orthotropic properties specified (E_L, E_T, G_LT when relevant)
• •✅ Environmental factors identified (C_M, C_T, C_CH applicable?)
• •✅ Time effect factor noted (λ for load duration)
• •✅ Resistance factor specified (φ varies by failure mode)
• •✅ Direction clarified (longitudinal vs transverse loading)
• •✅ Multiple limit states checked (GFRP has 3-4+ competing modes)
• •✅ Units specified (ksi, in, kip, °F)
• •✅ Variable definitions from symbols.md
• •✅ Serviceability noted (deflection often governs)
• •✅ Testing requirements mentioned (ASTM D6121, D7290 when relevant)
• •✅ Working Python code for calculations (tested and validated)

Special Features: GFRP-Specific Considerations

Critical Differences from Steel/Aluminum Design

1. Orthotropic Behavior

Steel/Aluminum: Isotropic (E_x = E_y = E_z) GFRP: Orthotropic (E_L ≠ E_T ≠ E_TT, typically E_L = 2.5×E_T)

→ Must specify direction of loading and properties

2. Time-Dependent Strength (Creep Rupture)

Steel/Aluminum: No time effect GFRP: Significant time effect (λ = 0.60-1.00)

→ Apply λ factor for all load combinations based on duration

3. Environmental Sensitivity

Steel: Minimal (corrosion is durability, not strength issue) Aluminum: Moderate (HAZ from welding) GFRP: High sensitivity to moisture, temperature, chemicals

→ Apply C_M, C_T, C_CH factors (can reduce capacity 30-50%)

4. No Yielding (Brittle Behavior)

Steel: Ductile with yielding plateau GFRP: Linear-elastic to brittle failure (no warning)

→ Lower φ factors (0.50-0.85 vs steel's 0.75-0.90)

5. Low Stiffness

Steel: E = 29,000 ksi GFRP: E = 2,000-4,000 ksi (~1/12 of steel)

→ Deflection often governs design, not strength

6. Multiple Buckling Modes

Steel: Typically 1-2 buckling modes GFRP: 4+ buckling modes (flexural, local flange, local web, torsional, flexural-torsional)

→ Check all modes separately

7. Complex Connection Design

Steel: Typically 2-3 failure modes GFRP: 6+ failure modes (bearing, net tension, shear-out, block shear, pull-through, bolt shear)

→ Connections often critical (φ as low as 0.50)

8. Temperature Limits

Steel: Up to ~1000°F GFRP: T_g typically 180-250°F (absolute limit)

→ Verify T_service < T_g - 20°F

When to Use Specification vs Commentary

Use Specification when:

• •User asks "what is the formula?"
• •User needs official requirements or limits
• •User wants to perform calculations
• •User asks about design criteria

Use Commentary when:

• •User asks "why is this required?"
• •User needs background or research basis
• •User wants to understand design philosophy
• •User asks "what's the difference from steel?"

Use Both Together when:

• •Comprehensive design questions
• •Teaching/learning scenarios
• •Formula explanation with practical context
• •Validation of complex calculations

Use References when:

• •Quick property lookup
• •Factor value tables
• •Symbol definitions
• •Chapter navigation

Error Handling

Common Scenarios

1. •

   Material properties not specified:

   • •Ask user: "Have you conducted ASTM D6121 testing for characteristic values?"
   • •Provide typical ranges for preliminary design only
   • •Emphasize: Final design MUST use test data
2. •

   Environmental conditions unclear:

   • •Ask user: "What are the service conditions? (dry/wet, temperature, chemicals)"
   • •Explain impact of C_M, C_T, C_CH factors (30-50% reduction possible)
3. •

   Load duration ambiguous:

   • •Ask user: "What load combination? (dead+live, dead+snow, dead+wind, etc.)"
   • •Explain λ factor selection (0.60-1.00 depending on duration)
4. •

   Direction not specified:

   • •Ask user: "Is loading in longitudinal or transverse direction?"
   • •Explain orthotropic behavior (E_L ≠ E_T, F_L^t ≠ F_T^t)
5. •

   No results found:

   • •Suggest alternative keywords
   • •Check all document types (Specification, Commentary, References)
   • •Recommend chapter-structure.md for navigation
6. •

   Ambiguous query:

   • •Clarify with multiple interpretations
   • •Ask user: "Did you mean [option A] or [option B]?"
7. •

   Missing parameters:

   • •List required values for calculation
   • •Offer typical values for preliminary sizing (with disclaimers)
8. •

   Out of scope:

   • •Clearly state limitations (no FRP rebar, no FRP wraps, no filament wound)
   • •Suggest consulting manufacturer or conducting testing

Validation Checks

For all calculations:

• •✅ Verify orthotropic properties (E_L, E_T, G_LT all provided)
• •✅ Check environmental factors applied (C_M, C_T, C_CH)
• •✅ Check time effect factor applied (λ)
• •✅ Verify resistance factor (φ appropriate for failure mode)
• •✅ Check against ASTM limits (COV, sample size, characteristic value methodology)
• •✅ Verify temperature < T_g - 20°F
• •✅ Warn if parameters outside typical ranges
• •✅ Note all assumptions (bracing, load cases, environmental exposure)
• •✅ Cross-check multiple limit states (GFRP has 3-4+ competing modes)

Special Notes

LRFD Method - Only Design Approach

ASCE/SEI 74-23 uses LRFD exclusively:

LRFD Design Equation: $$R_u \leq \phi \lambda R_n$$

Where:

• •$R_u$ = required strength (factored loads per ASCE 7)
• •$\phi$ = resistance factor (0.50-0.85, varies by failure mode)
• •$\lambda$ = time effect factor (0.60-1.00, varies by load duration)
• •$R_n$ = nominal resistance (based on characteristic properties adjusted for environment)

Load Combinations: Per ASCE 7 (same as steel/concrete):

• •1.4D
• •1.2D + 1.6L + 0.5L_r
• •1.2D + 1.6L_r + (0.5L or 0.5S)
• •1.2D + 1.6S + (0.5L or 0.8W)
• •1.2D + 1.0W + 0.5L + 0.5S
• •1.2D + 1.0E + 0.5L + 0.2S
• •0.9D + 1.0W
• •0.9D + 1.0E

No ASD: Standard does not provide ASD conversion. If user asks about ASD, explain LRFD is the required method.

Testing Requirements

Critical: Material properties cannot be assumed - MUST be determined by testing.

Required Testing Standards:

• •ASTM D6121: Characteristic properties determination (statistical methodology)
• •ASTM D7290: Filled-hole compression and tension (for connection design)
• •ASTM D3039: Tensile properties
• •ASTM D3410: Compressive properties
• •ASTM D5379: Shear properties (V-notched beam method)
• •ASTM E1640: Glass transition temperature T_g

Statistical Requirements:

• •Minimum sample size: 10-30 specimens per configuration
• •Statistical basis: 75% confidence, 20% exclusion limit
• •F_characteristic = mean - k × std_dev (where k from t-distribution)

Version Tracking

• •Standard: ASCE/SEI 74-23 (2023 edition)
• •Published by: American Society of Civil Engineers
• •Always cite version in responses

Material Defaults (Preliminary Design Only)

If no test data available (preliminary sizing only):

• •E_L = 2,500 ksi (17 GPa)
• •E_T = 1,000 ksi (7 GPa)
• •G_LT = 400 ksi (2.8 GPa)
• •F_L^t = 30 ksi (210 MPa)
• •F_L^c = 20 ksi (140 MPa)
• •F_LT^s = 5 ksi (35 MPa)
• •ν_LT = 0.30
• •T_g = 200°F (minimum acceptable)

Warning: Final design MUST use manufacturer test data per ASTM D6121.

For comprehensive GFRP structural design work, this skill integrates:

1. •Code requirements from ASCE/SEI 74-23 Specification (Chapters 1-9)
2. •Background understanding from Commentary (Chapters C1-C9)
3. •Quick reference data from 8 reference guides (properties, factors, symbols)
4. •Automation tools from 5 Python scripts (search, lookup, calculations)
5. •GFRP-specific expertise (orthotropic, time effects, environmental sensitivity)

Always prioritize accuracy, cite sources, apply environmental and time effect factors, check multiple failure modes, verify material properties, and follow LRFD methodology.