TASK Review Checklist
1. Task Compliance
- • Requirements: All user requirements covered?
- • Scope: No unrequested features?
- • Goal: Solves the core user problem?
2. Completeness (Use Cases)
- • Structure: Name, Actors, Preconditions, Main Scenario, Alternatives, Postconditions.
- • Main Scenario: Step-by-step, clear system/actor actions.
- • Alternatives: Error handling, edge cases (empty inputs, network failures).
- • Acceptance Criteria: Specific, measurable, verifiable.
3. Compatibility
- • Terminology: Uses project terms?
- • Architecture: Respects existing constraints?
- • Integrations: correctly describes interaction with existing components?
4. Consistency
- • Internal: No contradictions between UC-01 and UC-02.
- • Naming: Same entities named identically.
5. Non-Functional
- • Performance: Metrics defined?
- • Security: Critical checks (auth, inputs)?
Criticality Protocol
- •🔴 BLOCKING: Missing UC, contradiction with User Task, unmitigated critical risk.
- •🟡 MAJOR: Incomplete scenarios, vague criteria, term mismatches.
- •🟢 MINOR: Typos, phrasing.