AgentSkillsCN

architecture-paradigms

交互式架构范式选择器与路由工具。适用于为新系统选择架构模式、对比各范式之间的权衡取舍、记录架构决策过程、评估架构方案与团队规模及领域复杂度的适配性、规划实施方案路线图时使用。切勿在已明确采用某特定架构范式时使用此技能——请改用相应的架构范式*技能(如六边形架构、分层架构、微服务架构等)。若需回顾现有架构——请改用架构评审技能。在做出架构决策之前,请务必使用此技能。即使您对自身需求尚不确定,也请先行查阅。

SKILL.md
--- frontmatter
name: architecture-paradigms
description: Interactive selector and router for architecture paradigms. Use when
  selecting architecture patterns for new systems, comparing paradigm trade-offs,
  creating architecture decision records, evaluating architecture fit for team size
  and domain complexity, planning implementation roadmaps. Do not use when implementing
  a specific known paradigm - use the specific architecture-paradigm-* skill (hexagonal,
  layered, microservices, etc.) instead. reviewing existing architecture - use architecture-review
  instead. Use this skill BEFORE making architecture decisions. Check even if unsure
  about needs.
version: 1.4.0
category: architecture-decision
tags:
- architecture
- patterns
- selection
- implementation
- adr
dependencies:
- architecture-paradigm-functional-core
- architecture-paradigm-hexagonal
- architecture-paradigm-cqrs-es
- architecture-paradigm-event-driven
- architecture-paradigm-layered
- architecture-paradigm-modular-monolith
- architecture-paradigm-microkernel
- architecture-paradigm-microservices
- architecture-paradigm-service-based
- architecture-paradigm-space-based
- architecture-paradigm-pipeline
- architecture-paradigm-serverless
- architecture-paradigm-client-server
tools:
- paradigm-selector
- implementation-planner
- compatibility-checker
usage_patterns:
- paradigm-selection
- architecture-review
- implementation-planning
- adr-creation
complexity: intermediate
estimated_tokens: 280

Table of Contents

Architecture Paradigm Router

This skill helps you select the right architecture paradigm(s) for your system, then routes you to the specific paradigm skill for implementation details.

Quick Scenario Router

Match your needs to the recommended paradigm:

Your ScenarioPrimary ParadigmLoad Skill
Enterprise app with multiple teamsMicroservices or Modular Monolitharchitecture-paradigm-microservices or architecture-paradigm-modular-monolith
Complex business rules & testingFunctional Core, Imperative Shellarchitecture-paradigm-functional-core
Real-time/event processingEvent-Driven Architecturearchitecture-paradigm-event-driven
Legacy system modernizationHexagonal (Ports & Adapters)architecture-paradigm-hexagonal
Cloud-native/bursty workloadsServerlessarchitecture-paradigm-serverless
ETL/data processing pipelinePipeline Architecturearchitecture-paradigm-pipeline
Simple CRUD appLayered Architecturearchitecture-paradigm-layered
Command/query separationCQRS + Event Sourcingarchitecture-paradigm-cqrs-es

3-Step Selection Workflow

Step 1: Define Your Needs

Primary Concerns (select all that apply):

  • Testability: Isolate business logic → functional-core or hexagonal
  • Team Autonomy: Independent deployment → microservices or modular-monolith
  • Infrastructure Flexibility: Swap databases/frameworks → hexagonal
  • Real-time Scaling: Variable loads with events → event-driven or space-based
  • Simplicity: Maintainable without complexity → layered or modular-monolith
  • Legacy Integration: Work with existing systems → hexagonal or microkernel

System Context:

  • Team Size: < 5 → Layered/Functional Core | 5-15 → Modular Monolith | 15-50 → Microservices | 50+ → Microservices/Space-Based
  • Domain Complexity: Simple → Layered | Moderate → Hexagonal/Modular Monolith | Complex → Functional Core/CQRS | Highly Complex → Microservices/Event-Driven

Step 2: Evaluate Paradigms

Based on your needs from Step 1, review these options:

For Testability & Business Logic

  • Load architecture-paradigm-functional-core - Isolates business logic from infrastructure
  • Load architecture-paradigm-hexagonal - Clear domain/infrastructure boundaries

For Team Autonomy

  • Load architecture-paradigm-microservices - Independent deployment and scaling
  • Load architecture-paradigm-modular-monolith - Team autonomy without distributed complexity

For Infrastructure Flexibility

  • Load architecture-paradigm-hexagonal - Swap infrastructure without domain changes

For Simplicity & Maintainability

  • Load architecture-paradigm-layered - Simple, well-understood separation

For Real-time Event Processing

  • Load architecture-paradigm-event-driven - Scalable, decoupled processing
  • Load architecture-paradigm-space-based - In-memory data grids for linear scalability

For Legacy Integration

  • Load architecture-paradigm-microkernel - Plugin architecture for extensible platforms
  • Load architecture-paradigm-hexagonal - Adapters for external systems

Step 3: Load Paradigm Skill for Implementation

Once you've selected your paradigm(s), load the specific skill for detailed guidance:

bash
# Example: You selected Hexagonal Architecture
Skill(archetypes:architecture-paradigm-hexagonal)

The individual paradigm skill provides:

  • ✅ Complete implementation guide
  • ✅ ADR templates
  • ✅ Migration checklist
  • ✅ Code examples
  • ✅ Testing strategies
  • ✅ Risk assessments

Available Paradigm Skills

ParadigmComplexityTeam SizeBest ForSkill Name
Functional CoreMediumSmall-LargeComplex business logicarchitecture-paradigm-functional-core
HexagonalMediumSmall-LargeInfrastructure changesarchitecture-paradigm-hexagonal
LayeredLowSmall-MediumSimple domainsarchitecture-paradigm-layered
Modular MonolithMediumMedium-LargeEvolving systemsarchitecture-paradigm-modular-monolith
MicroservicesHighLargeComplex domainsarchitecture-paradigm-microservices
Event-DrivenHighMedium-LargeReal-time processingarchitecture-paradigm-event-driven
CQRS + ESHighMedium-LargeAudit trailsarchitecture-paradigm-cqrs-es
Service-BasedMediumMediumCoarse-grained servicesarchitecture-paradigm-service-based
ServerlessMediumSmall-MediumCloud-native/burstyarchitecture-paradigm-serverless
MicrokernelMediumSmall-MediumPlugin systemsarchitecture-paradigm-microkernel
Space-BasedHighLargeLinear scalabilityarchitecture-paradigm-space-based
PipelineLowSmall-MediumETL workflowsarchitecture-paradigm-pipeline
Client-ServerLowSmallTraditional appsarchitecture-paradigm-client-server

Integration with Other Skills

  • Architecture Review: Use this skill first to select paradigms, then /architecture-review for evaluation
  • Implementation Planning: Select paradigms here, then /writing-plans for detailed task breakdown
  • Refactoring: Identify target paradigms here, then use paradigm-specific skills for migration strategies

Exit Criteria

  • At least one paradigm is selected with clear rationale
  • Specific paradigm skill has been loaded for detailed guidance
  • Ready to create ADR or implementation plan

Next Steps

  1. Load the specific paradigm skill - Use Skill(archetypes:architecture-paradigm-NAME)
  2. Generate an ADR - Use the paradigm's ADR templates
  3. Create implementation plan - Use paradigm's migration checklist
  4. Set up monitoring - Track success metrics from paradigm guidance